Dec
05

Slavery by any other name

By Anja Merret

If you're new here, click here to Receive Your 5 FREE Articles. Thanks for visiting!

Apologies to Shakespeare for mangling a lovely speech as presented so beautifully in the eternal love story of Romeo and Juliet.  It seemed appropriate somehow. So what thoughts about slavery then?

What led me to this topic was a website called GetAFreelancer. I somehow got there a few days ago and thought, what a good idea. Maybe I can earn a bit by offering copy writing services. I duly signed up and waited with bated breath for the first projects to drop into my mail inbox.

It took but a few minutes for the deluge to start. I was taken aback by the quantity of mail. Rubbing hands gleefully, I started checking the offerings. I was absolutely speechless. The offers go something like this. 500 word article for $1.5. Or 145 short product descriptions for a budget between $30 to $250. Bid on this!

Now even if people somehow manage to find a trick to write articles very quickly, it still seems an amazing low rate to get paid. It takes me a good two hours to write a blog post with all the links I usually add to the content to make it more interesting.

How would I be able to compile regular European Soccer Reviews for a similar budget. Or how about a Project for WriteSmart for ONLY $4. Their caps. The only way anybody could make a living with this would be to scrape content off other websites. And changing elements to somehow be able to get away with it. Fraud with other words.

Whatever it is, there seems to be a demand as I get about four to six mails of lists of project offers per day. And for GetAFreelancer to continue to send out these huge quantities of offers people must be willing and able to perform these copy writing feats.

Along similar lines of slavery, I also discovered oDesk at about the same time. This is a ‘lovely’ little application that home workers instal on their PCs and the boss, wherever he might be can check on every move you make on your PC.  Hook up a webcam and the intrusion into your privacy is complete.

No chatting on Facebook during working hours anymore. The application takes screenshots of what’s happening on your computer at regular intervals. Sophisticated features analyse your time spent on work, your offline time and levels of productivity and compiles reports to send through. Big brother watches every move you make, even the times you don’t move anything.

It seems to be the most intrusive application I have ever seen. The boss has the luxury, so to speak, of not having to pay office space for his staff, or provide coffee and tea never mind paid leave and any other benefits such as pension or medical aid contributions.

The boss can actually check your work far more effectively than he could ever before in an office environment. He has rid himself of the idea of a permanent staff member and is now able to exploit the worker totally without any benefits in return.

What seems to be happening in the business world is that the benefits that people had and which induced them to enslave themselves to mindless and monotonous jobs are no longer offered. What made people work like robots was a trade off to get safe monthly salary payments with a possible pension to retire with.

Now they work at home, for a pittance and still have the boss lurking, watching, controlling and punishing if things don’t go his way.  If the freelancer does not deliver on some arbitrary targets then they just don’t get any more work. So you could be sick for a day, or have drama with small kids and that would be the end of your freelance work.

In effect, what has happened, is that companies using this service have taken away the previously regular work environment where unions and legislation gave the worker some protection. In its place we find that the worship of the god of profit has enslaved the worker even more. What has been removed are the few benefits that workers had fought so hard for. In its place a slavery of even greater magnitude.

Bookmark and Share
Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Google
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • TwitThis
  • Live
  • LinkedIn
  • Pownce
  • MySpace

10 Comments

1

yeah it’s bad. Unfortunately technology enables greedy humans to oppress others in wonderful new ways. Eventually robots will be doing most of the work, but until then it will get worse for the bottom end of the work force.

2

Totally agree with you.

Very sad. And we buy into it, don’t we.

3

You can call it what ever you like but you can’t do anything about the smell.

4

On the one hand, consumers want all for free - on the other hand, the consumers are in general, also earners who want good incomes!

Paying lower salaries forces some to consider other sources of income and others to rduce the quaity of their work as they have less time, motivation. etc.

Is this not going to explode at some time?

5

@Dawd. That is an excellent point you make. It’s back to the consumer again then isn’t it.

6

Ah but you and I are still at choice. We get to decide what work we will do. An employee is the true slave. Self-employment is the only true freedom and we seize it by creating original products, programs and services not by hiring out.

7

Yeah, I found the same two websites and had the same exact experience. I haven’t yet closed my accounts but I have no intention of working for anyone for so little money. Not unless my landlord, the grocery stores, the electric company, the oil company, and a whole host of other people who like to take my money would like to also get paid a whole lot less.

8

@velvet verbosity thanks for your comment. Agree with your sentiment. And like your blog too.

9

Anja - I agree with much of that you’ve said - but there is clearly another side to this coin.

If someone in a developing country can earn $5 for 2 hours of work all the best to them. Clearly many people won’t except these staggering lows but let’s put it all in perspective.

You get what you pay for is often the case. Someone may pay for $50 for a 5 page sales letter - and they’ll get a mish mash of ineffective slop that generates no response.

But the buyers know what they are getting into. Anyone that can pay a provider $5 or less for 2 hours of work and expect stellar results should be in the loony bin.

In my mind these services are great. Sure, most of the time companies are looking for the lowest bidder, but sooner or later they learn that they need to pay more to get better quality. If they can get great quality for a low price both buyer and seller win.

Put simply, oDesk, rentacoder, Elance, etc aren’t the kind of places you should hang your shingle and expect to get rich. But it works for some and gives huge opportunity to others.

One last thing. Having used services that show what the provider is doing as they work - I know it sounds creepy but it actually is great. Since I can’t physically ‘work’ with the person, I have no idea how they are spending their time, and when you are paying them hourly, there needs to be an easy way to track progress. It’s really just a tool to develop trust so that both parties will feel comfortable and use the service.

My two cents.

-Mike

10

@ Tom Volkar. Yes, I totally agree with you. The employee is the true slave. Everybody has a choice: to be a slave or to be his own boss.

Leave a Comment